Showing posts with label feminism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label feminism. Show all posts

Friday, September 5, 2014

Joan Rivers, and not settling for women who are "good enough."

I understand the injunction not to speak ill of the dead, I do. Death doesn't occur in isolation, and the loss of a loved one leaves friends and family in mourning. In the case of a fondly remembered public figure, such as the recently passed Robin Williams, the number of those left grieving expands beyond an immediate circle of acquaintances to people who felt they nearly knew the deceased, and whose emotional lives are affected accordingly. Not speaking ill of the dead, in most instances, is a reminder not to let petty quarrels disrupt mourners in fragile states, to whom some small debt or slight pales in comparison to the enormity of their sadness. If a co-worker dies of cancer, it's in decidedly poor taste to remark that at least they won't be stealing your sandwiches from the fridge in the break room anymore; that much restraint, I don't think, is too much to ask.

To preempt accusations that I'm dancing on Joan Rivers's grave even before it's been dug, I'll say this: I'm not happy that a woman who loved and was loved is gone, but I'm not sad that a celebrity who built her fame by throwing marginalized people under the bus in the name of comedy can no longer continue to do so. In this case, exhortations not to "speak ill" of the dead have the potential to silence those who might speak up amidst the wave of hagiographic tributes to remind Rivers's admirers of the poison she injected into the entertainment industry; in this case, shushing Joan Rivers detractors for the sake of not speaking ill of the dead speaks of a willfulness to brush her significant wrongdoings under a rug indefinitely, for the sake of painting as a saint a woman who was anything but. Prioritizing a narrative of Joan Rivers as pioneering female comedian over Joan Rivers as unapologetic, harsh-tongued critic of other women, minorities, the LGBTQ population, et cetera (and there's a lot of et cetera there) means posthumously forgiving her for a lifetime of cruelty masquerading as humor. Some people aren't ready to do that, and I don't blame them.

Time Magazine was quick to hit the hyperbole button with their coverage of Rivers's death, calling her a "groundbreaking feminist icon." Personally, I read those words and heard a loud record scratching noise, hoping that Time Magazine now publishes satirical news pieces; unfortunately, not so. Someone's rebuttal was that Joan Rivers is a woman of historical significance in the same way Margaret Thatcher was: the first of her kind, but not the best and, arguably, one of the worst. The trend towards labeling all influential women "feminists" is one that increasingly worries me, not because I feel the need to jealously guard the label as an honorific to be earned, but because lumping together the likes of Margaret Thatcher with Michelle Obama and Joan Rivers with Amy Poehler, Jessica Williams, and Mindy Kaling demeans the very notion of women rising to the top by virtue of talent rather than gender. The word "groundbreaking" is fair enough to ascribe to Thatcher and Rivers, as they were certainly the first women to make significant inroads in Western politics and mainstream comedy, but being female and being a "feminist icon" are not at all one and the same. To heap too much praise upon Joan Rivers for being the "first female comedian" doesn't only serve to state that she did it, but implies that she was the only one who could have done it -- that had she not made her culturally altering appearance on the comedy scene, no other woman could have. That's an insult to all women. Rivers was the first, but she didn't necessarily have to be; she simply happened to be, albeit through hard work and determination, but also through a coincidence of timing.

Moreover, Rivers herself disclaimed the title of feminist, and at least in doing so, her actions aligned with her words. A quick search on any form of social media right now will net a wealth of Joan Rivers "jokes" of the variety that people found funny and of the variety people found offensive; most of the time, they overlapped. Just a very limited sampling of such instances:

  • Used the occasion of Adele's Oscar win for "Skyfall" to make a fat joke about her statuette wearing Spanx
  • Took a posthumous shot at Amy Winehouse, two years after her death by alcohol intoxication, by remarking that it was "the longest she ever went without a drink"
  • Called Kim Kardashian's baby, a mixed-race six-month-old child, "ugly" and "desperately in need of a waxing"
  • Thought it appropriate to respond to Rihanna's confession that she still loved Chris Brown, who brutally beat her within the context of their relationship, with the words, "Idiot! Now it's MY turn to slap her!" She later followed up with faux concern, telling Rihanna that if he hit her once, he was likely to hit her again -- as if Rihanna needed Joan Rivers to tell her that.
  • Compared staying in her daughter's Malibu guest bedroom to the plight of the three women (Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight) Ariel Castro kidnapped and locked in his basement for ten years, and followed it up with, "There is nothing to apologize for. I made a joke. That's what I do" -- as if making jokes were an action entirely without consequence.
  • Supported fellow offensive person, Alec Baldwin, by letting loose a string of slurs: "Everybody just relax. Everybody’s either a w*p, a n###a, a k!ke, a ch%nk, a f@iry, a m$ck — everybody’s something so why don’t we all just. Calm. Down." She then helpfully clarified that this applies especially to "the Indians — both dot and feather!"
  • Used the n-word liberally, then railed against how "PC" the world is for censoring/censuring her.
  • Insulted Gwyneth Paltrow's appearance while making a Helen Keller joke -- an impressive two-in-one feat, really.
  • Demeaned Palestinians on multiple occasions, claiming they "deserve to be dead," calling those who didn't "get out" when told to get out (reminder that it's just about impossible for Palestinians to leave Gaza!) "idiots," and rejoicing that "at least the ones that were killed were the ones with low IQs." She blamed the election of Hamas on a population of "very stupid people that don't even own a pencil." She never apologized.
These are not frivolous complaints. To stopper up criticism of words that hurt people -- because no, jokes are never just jokes when one person is laughing and another is crying -- is to reinforce a hierarchy in which rich, famous, white women like Joan Rivers get to enjoy indemnity for causing genuine distress to the very people who most need laughter to heal them. Joan Rivers's family and friends will not be swayed in their sadness by online commentary on their mother's/cousin's/friend's despicable treatment of others, but the people who were the butt of her jokes will have their pain compounded by a flood of those who say their pain matters less than one mean old woman's mocking laughter. I'm not thrilled that Joan Rivers is dead, but I look forward to the day when her cruel legacy joins her in the grave.

Listen, fellow feminists: we don't have to settle for women like Joan Rivers as our icons, no matter what Time Magazine tells us. She was a woman, and she did great things (in magnitude, if not in beneficence), but we need to set higher standards for ourselves than that. There are so many great women in this world who uplift their fellow women, who understand the intersectionality of oppression and the value of empathy, who use their platforms -- whether in politics, the arts, science, fashion, media, entertainment -- to do more good than harm. It should surprise no one that some of these women can even be funny! And that's the kicker here: we don't have to settle for the Joan Riverses of the world, who are female without being feminist. We can make it known that women who are funny, but for whom "problematic" is an understatement, aren't good enough anymore, because there are better women out there. Let's raise the bar.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Male and female brains wired differently, according to scientists who should be fired.

According to an article in The Guardian based on a recently published study in PNAS entitled Sex differences in the structural connectome of the human brain, "scientists have drawn on nearly 1,000 brain scans to confirm what many had surely concluded long ago: that stark differences exist in the wiring of male and female brains." As a woman having read just the eight-word headline ("Male and female brains wired differently, scans reveal"), my knee-jerk reaction is that this must be wrong, cannot possibly be good science; as a former cognitive psychology student having read the entire news article and as much of the journal article itself as are available to me, my more rational, analytic response is still that this is wrong, and is not good science.

But which is the lady brain? Neither is pink...
National Academy of Sciences
This is blatant intellectual dishonesty, and both this writer and the researchers themselves should be ashamed. As unthinkable as it is that an entire team of Princeton researchers could draw such wildly inappropriate conclusions from their research, it is even more disheartening to consider the reasons why they might have done so. They argue that patterns of neural connectivity divide along gender lines, where "men's brains apparently wired more for perception and co-ordinated actions, and women's for social skills and memory, making them better equipped for multitasking." For any Neuro/Psych students who are thinking, "Hang on, that's the opposite of everything we've learned about the development of the human brain, which is primarily influenced by its environment," you're right! This write-up and even the study's own abstract are bullshit. Here's the tip-off:
"Male and female brains showed few differences in connectivity up to the age of 13, but became more differentiated in 14- to 17-year-olds."
That is to say that pre-adolescent brains proved, in fact, to be more similar than different until a certain cultural/developmental turning point, which implies that differences in neural connectivity are a product of environmental influence, not based on any biological gendered difference. To be clear: that is exactly the opposite conclusion that this writer, and the researchers themselves are touting. They gloss over the obvious implications -- that these so-called "hard-wired" differences between men and women are the product of gendered roles being forced upon them and that, in turn, shapes their brain functioning --  and the difference between cause and effect in interpreting these results in order to serve lukewarm stereotypes that men are more X and women are more Y because they were made that way. This is not only an incorrect application of these kinds of research methods; it's irresponsible, incorrect, and absolutely disgraceful.

The science correspondent's bias is obvious in his lazy introduction about scientists confirming what the common-sense population "had surely concluded long ago" about women and men's inherently different ways of thinking -- nice universal generalization of your own opinions to society at large, way to go. Even more troubling is how readily one of the contributing researchers summarizes her findings in such complacently sexist terms:
"If you look at functional studies, the left of the brain is more for logical thinking, the right of the brain is for more intuitive thinking. So if there's a task that involves doing both of those things, it would seem that women are hardwired to do those better," Verma said. "Women are better at intuitive thinking. Women are better at remembering things. When you talk, women are more emotionally involved – they will listen more."
Even the official news release from UPenn piles on the hackneyed stereotypes:
"For instance, on average, men are more likely better at learning and performing a single task at hand, like cycling or navigating directions, whereas women have superior memory and social cognition skills, making them more equipped for multitasking and creating solutions that work for a group. They have a mentalistic approach, so to speak."
Women are more intuitive and better listeners, of course! Of course, of course. They are also better equipped to cook and clean because their brains are smaller in size, and thus cannot handle the cognitive load required for higher-order tasks like running a business, leading meetings, or being ordained into the Catholic Church. Men are better at learning -- all types of learning, all the time, no matter what. That's why they're so much smarter.

I had assumed this kind of thinking went out of fashion along with phrenology, but sometimes I can be wrong, too. I eagerly await follow-up brain scan studies confirming that white men are more likely to succeed in leadership positions, black women don't feel pain, and Asians are better than everyone else at math.

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Standing with Wendy.

I planned to go to bed early tonight, but I made the mistake of tuning in to the online live stream of the Texas Senate's special session. State Senator Wendy Davis (D-TX, Fort Worth) was filibustering Senate Bill 5, a piece of anti-abortion legislation that would inevitably be passed by the Republican majority if put to a vote. SB 5 proposes to prohibit late-stage abortions under criminal penalties and effectively reduce the number of health clinics performing abortions in Texas from 42 to just 5 by imposing new requirements forcing clinics to undergo certification as "ambulatory surgical centers" and mandating that clinic doctors have admitting privileges at local hospitals -- conditions that, in their absence, have never before interfered with clinics' ability to perform safe, necessary medical procedures. In order to avoid giving Republicans the chance to pass the bill, Senator Davis announced her intention to filibuster, i.e. to remain on the floor discussing the bill for the 13 hours remaining until midnight, when the special session would be required to close without having had the chance to vote. Because the Texas Senate only convenes once every two years, with the exception of governor-mandated special sessions like this one, the legislation would have been tabled until 2015.

AP/Eric Gay
I'd been watching parts of Senator Davis's remarkable performance on and off throughout the day, as she read to a predominantly-male Senate a series of testimonies by Texas women who'd had firsthand experience needing abortion services. Not being allowed to sit, lean, eat, drink, use the bathroom, or otherwise move from an upright standing position during the filibuster, Senator Davis wore comfortable neon-pink running shoes for her very lengthy speaking engagement. She was holding up well, until the third time a Senator called for a Point of Order due to to Senator Davis allegedly breaking the filibuster rules. The first time was for introducing a topic that was not "germane," which is to say relevant, to the discussion of the abortion bill; the second was because she received physical assistance from another senator handing her a back brace midway through her lengthy standing session; the third and final interruption was again a claim that discussing Texas's newly passed ultrasound law was somehow off-topic when discussing abortion. I didn't witness the first two objections, but the third is definitively nonsense: by no stretch of the imagination are ultrasounds -- which Texas now requires for all women undergoing abortions -- NOT related to the bill at hand.

In short, with about two hours remaining on the clock for Senator Davis's filibuster, the remaining time was filled with an almost comically confused back-and-forth between senators about parliamentary procedure, like first-graders arguing over whose turn it is to play with the toy truck, or a particularly inept rendition of Who's On First. The Democratic minority senators backed her up, with Senators Leticia Van de Putte and Kirk Watson in particular providing robust appeals of the appeals to the filibuster (it got complicated). Senator Van de Putte, having been overlooked in earlier parliamentary proceedings, triggered the night's final push with only ten minutes left to midnight when she directly addressed the President of the Senate to ask, "At what point must a female senator raise her hand or her voice to be recognized over her male colleagues?” The thousands of citizens watching and listening from the balcony erupted, and the cheering drowned out any attempts at legislation until midnight had safely passed.

The sinister twist to the story is what happened next: the Senators huddled -- literally huddled, in a small mob of suits and thinning hair -- and took a vote anyway, two minutes past their deadline. They claim to have passed SB 5 with a vote of 17-12 in favor, but the midnight deadline is non-negotiable, and that verdict is therefore illegal. No one is sure what happens now, but the thousands of protestors remain in and around the Texas Senate building awaiting confirmation either way. Department of Public Safety officers are handcuffing and forcibly removing them one by one, but the pro-choice supporters are stubborn, and they're there in droves.

I live-tweeted the situation, naturally. If anyone's interested, I'm trying out Storify for the first time to compile my take on the events as they happened:



[Update] Fast-forward to now. It's 3:30 a.m., and by the time anyone reads this, the cat will be out of the bag: SB 5 IS DEAD. Thank you, Wendy Davis; thank you, Leticia Van de Putte; thank you, Kirk Watson; thank you, Democratic senators whose names I didn't catch, women and men both. Thank you to all the avid Twitter users who kept the rest of the country informed while every single major news network slept. Huge shoutout to The Texas Tribune, whose live stream and live blog proved that local news isn't dead, and that we need it more than ever.

Nick Swartsell, via Texas Observer
I've never had an abortion, and I don't have any immediate plans to need one -- but then again, no one ever does. I'm also not a Texan, and definitely never intend to become one. Nevertheless, this was a personal victory for me, as it was for every single person in the country who may one day have to resort to this kind of reproductive care, and I'm glad I stayed awake to see it happen.

Friday, June 21, 2013

How (not) to make jokes about women.

This picture of me will be relevant later. I look okay, though, right?
[Note: this is not new, but it’s new to me, so I’m writing about it as if it were new to everyone.]

A little over a year ago, 4Chan, the sort of Reddit Lite image-sharing forum site where teenage boys go to feel something – anything – birthed a “hilarious” meme called “2/10: Would Not Bang.” It’s a spinoff of the 2010 “Butthurt Dweller” meme, which in itself subscribes to that brand of humor that strives for irony but trips over its own offensiveness: the acne-ridden, glasses-wearing, greasy-ponytail-sporting face of the meme makes judgmental comments about other people, even though he’s not such a hot item himself.

The joke is in the irony, of course, because what right does some video-game-playing nerd who lives with his parents have to comment on anyone else? Just as much of a right as anyone else, arguably, but there’s potential for a genuine laugh in the contrast between “Complains about being bullied in school / Calls everyone a faggot online” or “Complains that girls only like attractive guys / Likes girls because they are hot.” That’s incisive, and it’s based in truth – there really are people like that, and I tend to be okay with making fun of people who make fun of other people. (Note that I don’t apply this eye-for-an-eye philosophy in other areas of my life.)

“Butthurt Dweller” isn’t a name I totally love, though, because in simple terms: butthurt → reference to anal sex + male character → insinuations of homosexuality + intention to be humorous → gay people are funny because ew = homophobia. So BD, as we’ll call him, is often paired up with captions specifically leveling ridiculous criticisms of women, like “Girl I stalk is holding hands with some guy / WHORE.” That’s hilarious, because it’s a clearly unfair accusation borne out of the character’s bitterness rather than reality. However, there’s a difference between jokes that establish BD as a jerk then play off that, and jokes that assume BD’s worth is tied up in his attractiveness. He looks like this:


…and that joke only works because the viewer agrees that this is a wildly unattractive guy who would never have a shot with any woman, period. That’s pretty shallow.

The “2/10: Wouldn’t Bang” meme arose from this shared agreement between meme-maker and audience that BD doesn’t get girls, so it’s super ironic of him to be so critical of women when, again, he looks like this:


So 4Chan users ran with the joke, creating “2/10: Would Not Bang” as a sort of competition to see who could come up with the most ridiculously unfounded criticisms of beautiful women, starting with comments Photoshopped over an image of actress/model/WWE fighter/George Clooney’s girlfriend Stacy Keibler in her underwear: her eyebrow arch is too extreme, her bra and panties don’t match, her bracelet isn’t authentic quartz, the curtains are wrinkled, 2/10: WOULD NOT BANG. This, I submit to the jury, is good comedy. What isn’t so funny are the memes that came after it:


Did you catch that? “Fat ass pinky” is funny; “rope should be around neck” is horrifying. Implying that a woman should commit suicide is never funny, and even less so here because it’s so out of the blue: why, exactly, should that rope be around her neck? Because she’s, ha ha, not pretty enough? That’s sick, and whoever “would not bang” this woman is definitely not someone I would bang, or let my friends bang.

An image of Angelina Jolie, voted Most Beautiful Woman in the World (probably by a bunch of heterosexual men) like, a million times, is great fodder for this meme:


“Ears too high for head,” “nose bridge too straight edged,” and “hideous mole” (pointing to maybe a two-pixel blemish) are all outlandish comments to make about Angelina Jolie. This meme succeeds, but it’s one of the few that does so without taking a sharp turn away from humor into perpetuating legitimately offensive comments about these women’s appearances:



The first example is straight-up rude. “Forehead cut off” is worth a laugh because duh, how irrelevant to someone’s appearance, but “big ears,” “big man shoulders,” and “boobs too small” are likely contenders for things that girl has actually thought about herself, looking in the mirror on a particularly rough day. Irony succeeds when it presents a view that contrasts sharply with someone’s expectations, like if a picture of Dolly Parton were captioned “boobs too small, would not bang,” but this fails to do that.

The second example, which not only repeats the not-so-funny “Jew nose” joke while introducing the term “gypsy,” which is a racial slur, also completely misses the point. The girl’s cleavage really isn’t presented from the best angle there, so calling it “Grand Canyon cleavage” is just doubling down on an actual, if infinitesimally minimal, flaw in her picture. “Roger Rabbit teeth” doesn’t make sense: her teeth aren’t big enough to merit derogatory comments, but they’re not so small to make that criticism truly outlandish, either. “Rings from extensive goggle usage”…well, that’s just not funny, try again.

According to an article by Slacktory, a self-identifying “comedic blog about the pop culture of the internet,” Would Not Bang is the funniest thing going (or at least it was in 2012; again, sorry for my much-belated outrage). According to me, a self-identifying woman with 21+ years’ worth of experience as a punch line for jokes about making sandwiches and being a bad driver, it’s more inadvertently misogynistic garbage masquerading as satire that buries any actual comedic value under a dump truck’s worth of humor that laughs at women, not with them. Sure, there are a few examples of men being subjected to the Would Not Bang treatment, but the Slacktory gallery at least didn't bother to include any. At any rate, this is just one example of the myriad ways our society normalizes putting women on display like museum exhibits; while it might be flattering to treat someone like art, it also makes them an object, potentially one that can be bought and sold. People aren’t paintings, and they’re worth more than face value.

Some of the meme creators used pictures of celebrities; others used pictures that, worryingly, look to be pulled off a Facebook page, not necessarily with the subject’s consent. I can’t do anything about that, but what I can do is present my version of the 2/10: Would Not Bang meme with myself as both joke-maker and joke-taker, using a picture that I thought I looked at least good enough in to send to my boyfriend (although the kissyface IS a joke). Female-authored comedy right here, everyone:

Hideous.